The Bottom Line On Choosing A New Floor “A Quick Reference Flooring Guide”

One of the most important aspects when remodeling a room is the flooring.  The right floor can make the difference between a nice room and a spectacular one.  Yet, how do you decide what type of flooring to choose? Time after time I have been asked by customers “what kind of floor should I use?”  They turn to me because they know that I am a handyman and that I have quite an extensive background in flooring. 


Unfortunately, the answer is not easy because there are many things that need to be taken into consideration.  Things like how much and what type of traffic the floor will be getting along with the part of the house the floor is located in are all questions that need to be answered. And, along with that there are other factors that need to be taken into consideration.  Other factors like budget and understanding that the floor that you may like best may not always be the best choice. 


I know of one home that has laminate flooring installed in their basement.  Now, anyone who has any experience with flooring will tell you that a laminate floor is a poor choice for a basement, because should their ever be a flood the laminate will get ruined.


But, the good news is choosing the right flooring does not have to be that difficult if you just have a proper understanding of the different floors available along with the pros and cons of each one. So what I have done is create a short list of the 5 most common floors available along with their benefits and drawbacks.  Let’s take a look.


Carpet - the usage of carpet varies by locale, but carpet is a soft fabric that works great in any room.  Carpet is made by inserting or as it is known in the trade, tufting small pieces of fabric, usually nylon, polyester, olefin or wool into latex backing.


The pros - carpet comes in many styles to fit almost any décor and budget.


The cons - although some carpet fibers wear better than others, carpet does not wear as well as other flooring choices.  Also, it is easily damaged and is more difficult to clean than other flooring materials.


Laminate - laminate floors, although made to look like natural products (wood and stone) are actually comprised of a synthetic or of a synthetic and natural base material coated with a synthetic covering with a picture of the material that they are supposed to replicate slipped in between.


The pros - laminate floors are less expensive than real woods or stone and at least for wood, more durable.  Laminate floors are very easy to clean and require less maintenance than wood or stone.


The cons - they do not quite look like real wood and stone although some of the latest products are getting very close.  They also can be damaged and as for wood are more difficult to repair.  Also, you do not want to use laminates in any area that may be subject to water because due to their construction they cannot get wet.


Tile and stone - tile is created out of a mixture of clays that once formed into shape are baked with a glaze applied to the top.  Tile is also being created out of porcelain.  Stones come in many materials including marble, granite, travertine, limestone and slate.


The pros - tile and stone floors are extremely durable.  They also give off a very elegant look and feel.


The cons - stones can be stained if not protected and can both tile and stone are subject to cracking.  Natural stones and better grade tile can also be costly.  Installation is also difficult because of the weight.



Vinyl - comes in two forms, tiles and sheet goods.


The pros - vinyl comes in a wide variety of choices and is inexpensive compared to other flooring materials.   Vinyl also wears well and is easy to maintain.


The cons - vinyl can be slippery and although vinyl tiles are easily installed by do it yourselfers, vinyl sheet goods are best off being left to the professionals.


Wood - comes in a variety of species and is broken down into two type’s – engineered and hard wood.  The difference between the two is that engineered wood flooring is produced by adhering layers of plastic laminate veneer with real wood.  Hard wood is solid wood.


The pros - wood is very elegant and easy to maintain. Wood also is very soft to walk on as compared to other materials and is a good insulator.


The cons - wood is easily damaged, but unlike laminate is easily repaired.  Also like laminate flooring you need to be careful where it is installed because it does not hold up very well to moisture.


So there you have it, the five main categories of flooring along with the pros and cons of each.  Many people do not realize it, but when choosing a floor there are many factors that need to be taken into consideration.  I hope that this post eases the confusion. 


 “Also, feel free to try Donald Gardner for help with *floor plans*.”

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google
  • MisterWong.DE
  • Netvouz
  • Reddit
  • Simpy

13 Responses to “The Bottom Line On Choosing A New Floor “A Quick Reference Flooring Guide””

  1. Tom Thorne Says:

    What do you think about pergo flooring? We installed some at a house we used to live in and moved shortly after. So I wasn’t able to see how it held up. It did look very nice but it was expensive.

  2. admin Says:

    Hey Tom,

    Pergo was one of the first if not the first to produce laminate flooring. They make a very good product although others do as well. Real wood and stone which laminates are made to look like will even cost you more.

    How did you find the installation? Would you suggest it for the average do it yourselfer?

    Thanks for checking in!

    Scott Your Online Handyman

  3. Debbie Says:

    Hi Scott….this post was very informative to me b/c we are trying to decide on new flooring for our living room area. I wanted top of the line plush carpeting but after looking at our present berber carpet after all of the spills from visiting grandchildren I’m starting to agree that continuing the same wide plank “distressed wood” laminate we have in our kitchen/dining room may be a better option. Area rugs are a lot less expensive to clean and/or replace than an expensive carpet would be…..and I would be able to relax more not worrying about the spills etc.

    FYI…..we installed the laminate in our kitchen/DR ourselves and it was super easy…..I think I could’ve done it myself if it wasn’t for needing some pieces cut….my husband doesn’t let me operate his power tools… :)

    Debbie

  4. Matt Thompson | Mattheosis.com Says:

    Thanks for this good article . I have been looking into different ideas as to what we want to do with the kitchen.

    Best thoughts, Matt

  5. admin Says:

    Thanks Debbie, although the laminate can get scratched I would say that there is less chance of the laminate getting damaged than the carpet especially if you see that based on your usage the laminate is holding up well in the other room. Yes, laminate is not difficult to install and actually one of my favorite jobs. The cutting and measuring is the difficult part, but I love to tap those pieces and watch a floor appear. I have a question for you - what is under the carpet that is in the living room now? Scott

  6. admin Says:

    Hey Matt, thanks for stopping by! I hope that I was able to help. I have a pretty extensive background in flooring so do not hesitate to contact me if I can help you further. What kind of floor do you have in the kitchen now and what were you thinking of getting? Scott

  7. Kat Says:

    Hi! We’ve been thinking about doing stained concrete in our new home to help with cooling (we live in a hot climate)… what do you think about stained concrete? Are there any drawbacks?

  8. admin Says:

    Hey Kat, I have heard some very nice reviews for stained concrete. Unfortunately, however in my part of the country (northeast) we do not use concrete flooring and I do not have any first hand experience. What I have heard though is that it does help with cooling, you just need to be ready for the unexpected when it comes to the finished product. How it dries I understand is anybody’s guess. There are many factors with the concrete such as density and surface imperfections that will determine the final appearance. Please keep in touch, I really would love to know how it goes. Scott

  9. Kat Says:

    Cool. Imperfections are not a problem… It just produces floors with “personality”, lol. We’re looking to build within the next 3 or 4 years; right now we’re doing alot of research :).

    Thanks!
    Kat

  10. admin Says:

    How I love hearing that term “research” - way to many people get involved with jobs much to fast only to regret it later. Contact me if I can be of any further assistance.

  11. Den SeddoKEagesee Says:

    Very usefull post.
    Thanks.
    P.S. I like your writing style.

  12. Edward SeddoKEagesee Says:

    First of all congratulation for such a great site. I learned a lot reading article here today. I will make sure i visit this site once a day so i can learn more.

  13. admin Says:

    I very much appreciate the kind words Edward!

Leave a Reply

Entries (RSS)